Donna Seybold is one of three student-athletes in program history to play on two MAAC Championship teams (1987 & 1990), she is the only player to score in two NCAA Tournament games. Seybold was named MVP of the 1990 MAAC Tournament after she recorded 17 points, nine assists, and seven rebounds against Holy Cross in the championship game. 

The 1989-90 Metropolitan Player of the Year, Seybold, was the fifth 1,000-point scorer in program history, and she currently ranks ninth with 1,217 career points. She was inducted into the Manhattan College Athletic Hall of Fame in 2003.