McKenzie was a three-time All-MAAC selection, earning two First Team nods in her junior and senior years. She also took Third Team honors as a sophomore and was selected to the All-Rookie Team as a freshman. She narrowly missed becoming the first player in conference history to average 20 points and 10 rebounds per game in her senior season, finishing 16th nationally in rebounding at 11.1 rpg. to go along with 19.5 points per game. She finished her career with 45 double-doubles, including 19 as a senior.
McKenzie became just the second Rider player to compile more than 1,000 points and 1,000 rebounds, finishing third all-time on the program scoring list (1,619) and atop the rebounding list with 1,143. McKenzie led the Broncs to their first-ever trip to the MAAC Semifinals as a senior. Following her time at Rider, McKenzie went on to play professionally for three seasons in Portugal, Romania and Luxembourg.