| 2024 |
Ben Ortwein, Rider |
Mike McConie, Siena |
Steve Jensen, Siena |
| 2023 |
Killian McGinley, Fairfield |
Connor Henderson, Iona |
Steve Jensen, Siena |
| 2022 |
Austin Devereux, Rider |
Louie Giovi, Rider |
Sean Burke, Iona |
| 2021 |
Austin Devereux, Rider |
Garrett Giles, Iona |
Doug Holub, Fairfield |
| 2020 |
No Championship (COVID-19) |
| 2019 |
Jeffrey Peters, Saint Peter's |
Jared Nelson, Siena |
Sean Burke, Iona |
| 2018 |
Michael Christifulli, Siena |
Justin Burkhamer, Iona |
Sean Burke, Iona |
| 2017 |
Mike Winter, Saint Peter's |
Jake Holt, Siena |
Nick Dilio, Saint Peter's |
| 2016 |
Nick Dilio, Saint Peter's |
Paolo Matti, Iona |
Steve Jensen, Siena |
| 2015 |
Kevin Kramarski, Iona |
Kevin Kramarski, Iona |
Peter Falloon, Saint Peter's |
| 2014 |
Alex Taylor, Fairfield |
Corey Cullen, Canisius |
Peter Falloon, Saint Peter's |
| 2013 |
Steve Burak, Fairfield |
Jimmy Dengler, Loyola* |
Len Roberto, Fairfield |
| 2012 |
Jay Mulieri, Loyola* |
Bart George, Loyola* |
Peter Falloon, Saint Peter's |
| 2011 |
Don Denyse, Siena |
Scott Rainaud, Fairfield |
Matt Glovaski, Iona |
| 2010 |
Doug Hoppe, Iona |
Dylan Newman, Iona |
Tom Wronowski, Siena |
| 2009 |
Michael Mulieri, Loyola* |
Jay Mulieri, Loyola* |
Tom Beidleman, Loyola* |
| 2008 |
Michael Mulieri, Loyola* |
Don Denyse, Siena |
Len Roberto, Fairfield |
| 2007 |
Will Shriver, Loyola* |
- |
Tom Wronowski, Siena |
| 2006 |
Kyle Underwood, Iona |
- |
Chet Dalgewicz, Rider |
| 2005 |
Brian Bigley, Siena |
- |
Tom Wronowski, Siena |
| 2004 |
T.J. Shuart, Loyola* |
- |
Len Roberto, Fairfield |
| 2003 |
Jeff O'Brian, Loyola* |
- |
Tom Biedeleman, Loyola* |
| Former MAAC Member* |